14 Comments
User's avatar
Tony Lima's avatar

I vote for leaving it in. But it is, after all, your column!

Expand full comment
L G's avatar

It’s an interesting comment that I wouldn’t have expected… worthy of its own discussion. No reason one event can’t spawn two columns.

Expand full comment
Debra J. Saunders's avatar

True.

Expand full comment
Laura A Merlo's avatar

I see no reason why graduating students should have to listen, on one of the most celebratory day of their lives, to a speaker who advocates policies that would, in many cases, exclude students like them from getting an education.

I object to the quote not because it’s in Latin but because quoted in this context, it pretends that academia is in favor of less diversity when, actually, the movement has been for more diversity. In the dull and dishonest days, the limited curriculum (and speakers) amounted to a desert while today’s wider view of what is important to learn and the inclusion of people who were discriminated against before amounts to a flourishing educational environment.

Expand full comment
Debra J. Saunders's avatar

Please, tell me exactly what Zaslav said that you think would ruin anyone's day.

Expand full comment
Tony Lima's avatar

Let’s see. Ms. Merlo’s profile says this is her only comment. She does not subscribe to anything. Troll alert.

Expand full comment
Debra J. Saunders's avatar

Merlo could not or would not respond to my simple question. That's her profile.

Expand full comment
Jack Gmail's avatar

Agree with you. Reader would get sidetracked with trying to translate. And leaving it out gives you the opportunity to translate and explain in a second column.

Expand full comment
Debra J. Saunders's avatar

Thanks. Glad someone else sees it.

Expand full comment
Mitchel Benson's avatar

I woulda used it. Bottom line — it was wonderfully translatable. Some foreign language quotes not so much. Also, the showing up quote is words to live by.

Expand full comment
Debra J. Saunders's avatar

Thanks for chiming in. I like that Substack gives me a chance to get some audience reaction.

Expand full comment
Patricia Paulson's avatar

You should have left it in. The deacon at my church just gave us a handout during Bible Study about showing up by Brad Stulberg - For People to Really Know Us, We Need to Show Up.......

Expand full comment
Debra J. Saunders's avatar

You may be right that I should have left it in.

Expand full comment
Patricia Paulson's avatar

I forwarded your post to the deacon of my church.

Expand full comment